The dire importance of the comitatus is also seen in Beowulf through the theme of revenge, which is not present in Sir Gawain. As the years go by Beowulf becomes king and a dragon begins to stir. He wins by brute strength and stubborn determination. Genealogy is very important in the hierarchical society, so if he had failed he would not only bring shame to himself, but to his family and nation. He plans to cheat by using the magical power of the sash to save his life. Another major difference is in the spiritual realm. Both Represent Good These guys are both heroes, but their authors wrote them to purposefully represent the idea of goodness.
This particular contract also draws away from the importance of the comitatus because it involves the interest of only two men — if Beowulf received such an offer, it is likely he would split whatever he acquired amongst himself and his thanes. In the time of Sir Gawain Christianity was the widely accepted religion. Beowulf's world is centered by a warrior's reputation, where an individual is judged on the basis of his deeds. Beowulf was not only looking to become a hero, he wanted to reveal the importance of establishing identity. In conclusion, we have found many similarities when comparing the stories.
Sir Gawain also participates in challenges that define his character. Beowulf, as with all warrior societies, seemed to rely on spiritualism and ancient spells or relics. Even though both are heroes their heroic traits are different at times. Beowulf, an epic poem, and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, a romantic poem, are two great literary works, both with nameless and possibly countless authors, separated by literary genre and 6oo years of societal development. Honestly I personally prefered Sir. In the story, he faces three challenges from the Green Knight. The epic of Beowulf is the highest achievement of Old English literature that inherits the Germanic heroic tradition.
One major difference between the society that Beowulf lived in and the one Sir Gawain lived in is their views on religion. To begin with, both stories are set in wild, strange, and scary places. Beowulf's deeds are judged solely by others and they determine his adequacy in maintaining his role. On the contrary, Sir Gawain strives for excellence when it comes… 879 Words 4 Pages Beowulf vs. These heroes were also destined to become the savior of their time, with God in control of their lives.
What is especially interesting is that the way in which the tale is structured and narrated permits the reader to observe two different types of heroism: the heroism of youth and the heroism of an older, wiser, and more mature warrior. Sir Gawain is presented as a noble knight, who embodies chivalry; he is loyal, honest and above all, courteous. Their similarities are based mostly on the physical characteristics, but all the differences are caused by different ideals of their time. He represents moral rules that simply did not exist at the time of Beowulf, when the strength was a primary requirement for a warrior. Camelot is described as a prosperous place with a grand castle and many luxuries — in the time of Beowulf the structures that preserved the Anglo-Saxons were more or less gigantic huts.
In this passage, the significance of in these tales are explained by presenting how Beowulf and the characters of his time praised the Lord for all of his works, even those that pertained to evil doings, Sir Gawain praised the Lord for blessings and strength instead of his unfortunate times, and how each character was destined to become more like Christ, living their lives being heroes and God-like. Even though Lancelot killed his brothers, Lancelot was still a very noble knight. Differences are more common than similarities when Beowulf is compared with Sir. A major comparison would be their physical characteristics. An epic hero, of course is in an epic narrative, but it is what they accomplish in that specific text. Sir Gawain stays true to his word, and seeks out the Green Knight as promised. Beowulf voluntarily came to King Hrothgar so he could save his people.
It is evident, that ideals of the society prevail in the conduct of the people in any ordeals, and the ideals of the time make the hero who he is. Regardless of the situation, God was acknowledged as a miracle worker, a judge, or even just to praise him for the punish of the evil doers, and rewarding and protecting those that try to help others. This surely is not true, but to Gawain the valor is necessary. He is as courteous as brave: when the edge of the ax snipped his skin, he is ready to fight, but first he courteously speaks to his enemy. Beowulf, our earliest hero, is brave but his motivation is different than then other two.
However, the traits they have in common are far less numerous than those that set them apart. These two heroic figures were destined to be a savior for there people. Although he is a hero he is constantly aware of his own mortality, and it is in battle that his bravery is tested. Additionally, while he is willing to fight when needed, he doesn't typically go into fights with his sword already drawn. King Arthur never purposely set out to prove his worth, as both Beowulf and Sir Gawain did.
He even has patience with Sir Bedivere, who betrays his orders. The tales of these epic adventures acknowledged great faith in God, which to me, informs readers that God handles all kinds of miracles and sends us heroes to give us hope and faith of his good works. Beowulf were basically raised to believe that they were sent by God to handle the evil doers on the earth. Gawain believed that he probably would not have to take the blow from the Green Knight because he would kill the Knight with his blow. In the following paragraph you will see many similarities.
The rules of the game are set and Gawain swears to find the Green Knight again in a year. Beowulf is the main character of the epic poem of the same name - an epic poem is a really long poem that tells a serious story. Both of these heroes are obviously very highly viewed by those around them, although almost 600 years separates the writing of the two manuscripts. However, Beowulf was not the only hero during this time period. Sir Gawain and the Green Knight Formal Response Essay When comparing the two stories of Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, one can see many similarities and differences. Sir Gawain is also willing to rise during moments of trouble within his court but lacks the altruism that is inherent in Beowulf's leadership.